Tanking or cavity drain: which does your basement need?

The two main ways to keep a basement dry work very differently. Here is when each one is the right choice and why many basements use both.

The short answer

Tanking (Type A) stops water at the surface with a bonded barrier. A cavity drain (Type C) lets water into a cavity behind a membrane and pumps it away. Small, shallow spaces often suit tanking; deep or habitable basements usually suit a cavity drain, and higher-risk basements often combine the two.

GroundwaterGround levelDry basementWallBarrier coat

Simplified section through a basement wall. Not to scale.

Type A

Barrier protection

A waterproof render, slurry or screed is bonded to the inside of the structure and holds the water back at the surface.

Best for

  • Vaults and cellars where space matters
  • Walls that can take a bonded coating
  • Failed old tanking, using RenStrengthâ„¢
On our sitesSinclair Gardens: an 18 mm multi-coat treatment kept the vaults dry with no lining wall.Read the case study

Switch between the types to see where the water goes in each.

Type A: barrier protection (tanking)

A Type A system is bonded straight onto the walls, floor and soffit: cementitious renders and slurries, screeds or liquid membranes, built up in coats.

Because there is no lining wall, it keeps more of the room. It relies on a sound substrate and good detailing at every junction, and it resists water rather than managing it.

Type C: drained protection (cavity drain)

A Type C system uses studded membranes on the walls and floor. Any water that gets through the structure runs down the cavity behind the membrane into drainage channels and a sump, where a pump removes it.

It copes well with high water tables and movement in the structure, but the pumps and channels need regular servicing.

When each is the right choice

  • Vaults, cellars and small stores where space matters: often Type A.
  • Deep basements, pools and new living space: usually Type C.
  • Higher-risk or high-value basements: BS 8102 often calls for combined protection, such as Type A with Type C, or either with Type B waterproof concrete.
  • Failed existing tanking: our RenStrengthâ„¢ Type A system can often go over it without hacking off.

Getting the decision right

The right answer depends on the ground, the structure, the water table and how the space will be used. That is why BS 8102 asks for a waterproofing design, not just a product choice. A surveyor certified in structural waterproofing can assess the basement and design the system.

Not sure what you need?A qualified surveyor will find the cause and tell you straight.
Ask a surveyor

Related service: Basement & Structural Waterproofing